Tuesday November 1, 2011
Oversupply of retail and office space
By THOMAS HUONG
KUALA LUMPUR: The Klang Valley will face an oversupply of office and retail space within the next two to three years, according to property consultancy CB Richard Ellis (M) Sdn Bhd.
Capital values for residential units would see some increases in 2012, but at slower rates compared with the past 18 months.
CB Richard Ellis executive chairman Christopher Boyd said while 2011 was a strong year in terms of demand for office space in the Klang Valley, rental values might succumb to an oversupply situation within the next 18 months.
“Short-term demand for office space is stable but unlikely to grow sharply,” he said at a talk entitled Kuala Lumpur Property Market In Times Of Uncertainty, which was organised by MIDF Research here yesterday.
Boyd said that total office space supply in the Klang Valley stood at 80.8 million sq ft at the end of the first half of 2011 (compared with 80 million sq ft at the end of 2010).
However, it was estimated that an additional 25 million sq ft of office space would come onstream in the Klang Valley by 2015 (excluding mega projects such as the Naza group's KL Metropolis development, Warisan Merdeka tower and the Kuala Lumpur International Financial District).
According to Boyd, vacancy rates in Kuala Lumpur are under 13%.
“This is not an alarming number, but vacancy rates are expected to increase as more supply comes onstream.” A report by CB Richard Ellis also noted that prime gross asking rentals were flat at RM7 per sq ft with only a handful of buildings above this level.
Since rising steadily from 2002 to 2008, rentals at top city centre buildings have remained mostly flat for the past two years.
“Asking rents at most top buildings in the city centre are within the RM6 to RM10 per sq ft per month range, with only a few select buildings, such as Petronas Tower 2 and Maxis Tower, achieving monthly rents of RM10 per sq ft and above,” said the report.
Boyd said recent average transaction prices of Grade A office space generally range between RM800 and RM900 per sq ft. “But there are higher prices than these being achieved in the market. We have recently seen prices of RM1,100 sq ft or more in Kuala Lumpur Sentral and SP Setia Bhd's KL Eco City.”
Meanwhile, CB Richard Ellis managing director Allan Soo said that the Klang Valley would overtake Singapore in terms of retail space per capita. Soo said as of the third quarter of 2011, total retail space supply in the Klang Valley was 43.7 million sq ft in 133 shopping centres and hypermarkets which was equivalent to 7.1 sq ft per capita (based on population of 6.1 million).
“This is higher than Bangkok, Thailand which stands at about 6.5 sq ft per capita, and equivalent to Singapore. However, it is a landlords' market in Singapore where malls are well connected by MRT (mass rapid transit) and are doing well. In the Klang Valley, it is the reverse - the tenants are the kings.”
Soo estimated that by 2014, the Klang Valley will have 53 million sq ft of retail space in 149 malls and hypermarkets.
However, Soo pointed out that only about 43 shopping centres and hypermarkets out of the existing 133 (or 30%) were performing well.
A report by CB Richard Ellis said the next rental review for established shopping centres would be in 2013 and rents may hit RM122 per sq ft. On residential property, Boyd said the pace of capital appreciation would slow in the next two years as new supply come onstream. In the condominium segment in Kuala Lumpur, total supply grew by 11% since end-2010 to 63,994 units in the first half of this year.
The supply figures included all projects with average prices of RM350 per sq ft and above.
While there had been a shift in buyers' preference towards smaller and more affordable units, Boyd said average asking rentals have declined in prime areas of Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC) and Mont Kiara.
“In some cases in the KLCC area and and Mont Kiara, condominium rentals have halved in the last two years.” Rental rates in the three main condo markets (KLCC, Bangsar and Mont Kiara) on a per sq ft basis have declined since 2007, reflecting weaker demand for rental units coupled with increased supply.
Boyd also pointed out that new housing projects in the Klang Valley had begun to pick up in the first half of this year, with 15,030 units.
This is contrasted with a trend of falling incoming supply, new completions and housing projects in the Klang Valley since 2004.
From 2004 to 2007, there were new housing projects supplying more than 60,000 units each year.
However, the supply from new housing projects dipped to 41,583 units in 2008 and subsequently, between 22,000 and 25,000 in the following two years.
“The supply stream of new housing units fell in 2008. I do not think it was just the result of the global financial crisis. As building costs were rising sharply without selling prices coming up to match them, perhaps developers took the view they should hold back. And this contributed to the fast rising housing prices in the last two years.”